Hidden Valley Golf Course, where Caleb has worked for the past five years, was broken into twice in one month. The first break-in happened on a Sunday. When the window was shattered, the alarm sounded and scared the guys off. Unfortunately, they came back the very next Sunday. The window hadn’t been fixed yet, and the pro shop was still boarded up. Since no glass was broken this time, the alarm didn’t go off, and about $4,000 worth of golf clubs were stolen.
Caleb loves working at Hidden Valley, and he really likes his boss, Brad, so he was understandably upset that someone was able to break in and steal so much of their equipment. His first idea was what he called a “sting operation,” which involved him sleeping at the course on a Sunday night and catching the guy in the act. That idea was quickly shut down, and we also had to review the fact that he is not allowed to shoot someone under any circumstances.
Once he accepted that this probably wasn’t the best plan, he moved on to Plan B: tracking down the stolen clubs on Facebook Marketplace. Caleb sells golf clubs on Facebook all the time. He knows what every club is worth and is familiar with the main sellers in the area. He also learned that golf clubs have serial numbers, so he gathered the serial numbers from the stolen clubs and started watching listings online.
It didn’t take long. About a week later, a couple of kids listed some very high-priced golf clubs, advertising them as brand new—but without head covers. Caleb immediately knew that was a red flag since all new clubs come with head covers when purchased.
That’s when Phase 2 began. Caleb started messaging the kids and arranged a meeting to look at the clubs. At our request, he chose a very public location. Once he met with them and inspected the clubs, he knew he had his guys. While discreetly checking serial numbers, he noticed something else that caught his attention—several clubs had dried blood on them. During the break-in, the thief had cut his hand and left a large smear of blood on the pro shop counter.
Caleb acted unsure about whether he wanted to spend that much money and told them he’d get back to them. Then he stepped fully into his private investigator role. He told his boss what he had discovered, and together they contacted the police and coordinated a plan for a second meetup to purchase the clubs.
Caleb came home from school on Monday to finish the sting operation he had started. He went to the meetup location, accompanied by four unmarked police cars. Once he pointed out the seller, the cops boxed him in and arrested him. The guys were 18–19 years old, and Caleb said they were about as stupid as could be. One of them even asked the officer if he could text “Kale Lutz” to let him know he wouldn’t be able to meet him to sell the clubs—pretty funny.
The second guy was caught the same way. One is being charged with felony theft and breaking and entering, while the other received a lighter punishment since he was mainly helping his friend sell the stolen clubs.
Caleb takes his job seriously, and he wasn’t about to let some punk kid walk away with $4,000 worth of stolen equipment. While I’m not entirely comfortable with him playing private investigator for safety reasons, I couldn’t be more proud of him.

